5 most overrated fantasy QBs

Tyler Loechner takes a look at the five most overrated quarterbacks of the 2015 fantasy football season.

| 1 year ago
(AP Photo/Alex Brandon)

(AP Photo/Alex Brandon)

5 most overrated fantasy QBs


Quarterbacks are arguably the most divisive position when it comes to the fantasy football community. Do you play it safe with an Aaron Rodgers and Andrew Luck by taking one early? Or do you wait, and hope to grab a top-five talent in the later rounds?

The “wait on a quarterback” strategy has paid off for many fantasy owners, but it takes great discipline to wait on a quarterback. Their name, after all, is typically the first displayed when someone looks at your roster. An impressive name atop the roster makes your team look better.

If you can’t wait, you might over-reach for a quarterback that’s being overvalued. This article is not about whether or not you are better off taking Aaron Rodgers in the second round or Tony Romo in the seventh. Instead, we want to know: Which quarterbacks are the most overrated heading into the 2015 fantasy football season?

To read the entire article, please login or sign up for a PFF Fantasy Subscription

Not a PFF fantasy subscriber? Compare all of our packages and features here.



Tyler Loechner is a lead writer at PFF Fantasy. He has played fantasy football since 1999 and has been a part of the PFF Fantasy staff since 2010. Tyler was also previously a fantasy football featured columnist at Bleacher Report.

  • Andrew Dempsey

    So Brees is the guy? I’m not wasting a first or second round pick on a QB. Plus Russell Wilson is on a run heavy team.

    • Tyler Loechner

      Brees not a bad one. Wilson is on a run-heavy team, yes, but he’s also part of that. His legs score a lot of fantasy points.

  • Steven D.

    Did I miss the 5 most overrated Fantasy QBs somewhere in the article?

    • Tyler Loechner

      Hi Steven,

      It’s possible you weren’t logged into the PFF Fantasy Gold account when you looked at the article. The players were listed after the break!

    • Sweetbrandigirl2004

      You have to Pay to see the list I’m guessing !

  • travis

    They were also QB’s 4 (Peyton), 7 (Ryan), 9 (Brady), and 10 (Eli). The only good arguments here are Peyton declining and Brady being affected by the suspension. Stafford is definitely overrated, but the rest of this seems kind of irrelevant..

  • Ryan Osugi

    I think that it would be a little more helpful if you analyzed these in regard to impact on final rosters. For example, taking overrated (-2) Stafford in the 14th round as opposed to (-2) Ryan in the 7th actually means that drafting Ryan hurts your team more than Stafford would if you look at both in re: opportunities missed by expected points per round. Just throwing a bunch of -2/-3 guys at us isn’t actually helpful information unless you tell us how to take advantage of it.