Don’t blame Sam Bradford for Vikings’ struggles

Was the trade for Sam Bradford a mistake? Senior Analyst Sam Monson explains why the move was still a smart one.

| 7 months ago
Vikings QB Sam Bradford

(Photo by Hannah Foslien/Getty Images)

Don’t blame Sam Bradford for Vikings’ struggles

The Vikings dropped yet another game on Thursday, this time against the 11-1 Cowboys, losing their sixth game out of the last seven. Although things may look pretty hopeless for Minnesota right now, this team remains at .500, and is just a game back in the division (pending the results of the rest of Week 13).

It’s tough to think of a team that has been more consistently assaulted with injuries and losses to key personnel all season long than Minnesota, a team that had Super Bowl aspirations before the season began, and is now just desperately trying to reach the playoffs.

Quarterback Teddy Bridgewater’s presence on the sideline during the game against Dallas last night served only as a reminder of what might have been for this team.

When Bridgewater went down—due to a freak, non-contact injury before the season had even begun—the Vikings felt that this team was good enough on paper. The loss of Bridgewater was such a fatal one to the team’s season that they needed to make something big happen to address the position; hence, Sam Bradford’s arrival.

The trade for Bradford eight days before the season began sent Philadelphia the Vikings’ first-round pick in 2017, and a 2018 conditional fourth-rounder, that can rise as high as a second-round pick if Minnesota actually makes something of this season. The more this season unfolds, the worse that trade looks, but it remains a move that had to be made, and one that actually did what it was supposed to for this team.

Bradford is not the reason the Vikings have lost six games—though it’s fair to pin the second Detroit loss directly on him, I suppose, since his horrible interception wrapped that game up—but he is one of the biggest reasons behind a few of their first five victories.

Bradford’s play has dropped off as the season has worn on, but it’s almost a direct correlation to how badly the pass protection has deteriorated in that time. Matt Kalil had many faults as a starting left tackle, but the lowest grade he ever achieved over a season was 43.8 in 2014. Last season, he was at 68.4, but his replacement, T.J. Clemmings, is currently grading at 28.3, on a scale of 0–100. That is the fourth-lowest grade we have ever seen from an offensive tackle over a full season (since PFF began grading players in 2006), and the second-lowest from a left tackle, despite the Vikings trying to get rid of the ball as fast as humanly possible.

Vikings offensive line grades

Bradford now has the league’s fifth-fastest average-time-to-throw figure, at 2.3 seconds and that number has only been getting smaller as the year has progressed. He has the league’s lowest average depth of target, at 6.5 yards, lower even than pathologically conservative Chiefs QB Alex Smith. There is no offense in the game that makes life easier for its offensive linemen in terms of how long they have to block for, but the Vikings, and Clemmings in particular, just can’t hold up.

Early in the season, Bradford’s passer rating under pressure was a ridiculous 108.0. Typically, playing under pressure drops a QB’s passer rating in the region of 30.0 points, and this season, the league average passer rating under pressure is just 65.4. Even now, Bradford’s is still 87.5, the third-best figure in football behind only Tom Brady (93.6) and Russell Wilson (88.9).

Bradford may not be one of the league’s best quarterbacks, but he has played more than well enough for this team to compete offensively—if only the O-line had been even close to viable.

With the loss of Kalil, injuries at other spots, and just straight awful play at others, the Vikings’ offensive line, on its best days, has been average; on its worst, has been prohibitively bad. There are very few QBs in the league that could win games consistently with this kind of pass protection, even fewer within this offensive scheme, and Bradford not being one of them shouldn’t be held against him, or render the trade a mistake.

With Bridgewater’s injury still a major question mark, the Vikings may need Bradford for 2017. They can now concentrate on repairing that offensive line in the offseason, clearing out the dead weight, freeing up some cap space by jettisoning the exorbitant contract of Adrian Peterson that has hung from the salary cap like a millstone for awhile now, and actually remain in contention going forward.

Without the move for Bradford, it’s likely the team would be in a similar spot—maybe with a few more losses—but with that 2017 first-round pick intact, and potentially with a huge question mark at QB.

Minnesota’s season may well be unspooling; given the state of the NFC North, however, it is far from lost. The trade for Bradford remains a move the team had to make, for 2017 as much as for 2016. The single-biggest issue facing this team is not at QB, but rather how to repair an entire offensive line in the space of an offseason. Without successfully navigating that challenge, it really doesn’t matter who is at quarterback for the Vikings.

| Senior Analyst

Sam is a Senior Analyst at Pro Football Focus, as well as a contributor to ESPN and NBCSports.

  • GordonGekko

    The Eagles got their 1 st rd pick they gave to CLEV back with the Vikings.

    • Micheal Lien

      Cleveland picked a bad year to be #1 overall no definite superstar qb available if they were smart they would either take best available or trade back and still not take a qb trade a 3rd for bradford or glennon one of those tradable qbs mn should try to pry thomas with a bradford and a third pick

      • GordonGekko

        I can’t understand what your wrote. Did you ever learn how to write properly?

        • Micheal Lien

          Well i dont know if your actually asking me that or if your just being a jerk but all my classes relating to composition i didnt do well in because i spent that year and a half homeless missing alot of class or being to tired to comprehend

          • McGeorge

            Micheal, if you put a period ‘.’ at the end of your sentences, it will be easier to understand what you write.

  • JudoPrince

    Blame Minnesota’s management. Why on earth would you trade a number one pick for a limited, injury prone QB especially when pass protection has been a disaster the previous two seasons? That first round you gave away could have been used on a quality offensive lineman in the upcoming draft.

    • crosseyedlemon

      When no one on the offensive line can block effectively then the problem is either bad coaching or bad schemes (or both) and until that is sorted out and corrected, there is absolutely no point in using a first round pick on yet another offensive lineman.

      • György Márk Kis

        He is among the fastest in release, but that is still not enough :( Problem is, OL class isn’t that great next year…

        • tk

          Vikings need to trade some defensive depth for OL skill. They cannot. Treat qb’s as a disposable commodity. What can they get for Treadwell and Mackensie Alexander, maybe throw in Trea Wayne’s…

    • György Márk Kis

      “Injury prone”

      You remember when he got sacked 6+5 times in Philly and in Chicago? Well, he got up and did his job. Do tell me again, how is he injury prone from a ligament tear which is basically looming over every single player on field?

  • crosseyedlemon

    The real reason the Vikings have unraveled has less to do with injuries and more to do with their turnover ratio which was +11 through the first five games but is only +2 since their bye week.

  • Micheal Lien

    Tell you the truth kalil should get a contract one to two year prove it contract boone and easton i think are good need a new right tackle berger clemmings fusco battle for right gaurd clemmings has good ability for run blocking and could benefit to a move inside where lateral movement is limited as he is at it.

    • György Márk Kis

      I see more potential to be developed in Sirles actually.

  • Micheal Lien

    Oh and bradford trade thougg magical at first and hes managed well even in losses i dont understand the win now thing we have a young core on both sides of the football this year isnt the last year for anybody but maybe newman and greenway didnt need to pay out the house for him in a win now scenario next year could have tried to get that lt or rt needed now we have to hope fa or 2nd rd or beyond tackle is there whos starter capable

    • György Márk Kis

      Cap space and contracts are managable for next year. Smith is the highest paid safety already, major money pits are going to be Griffen, Hunter, Barr, Rhodes. Managable.

  • tk

    It was and still is a good trade. A big problem is having the Trea Waynes drafted no 11 two years ago sitting on the bench along with the top two picks from last year in Laquon Treadwell and Mackensie Alexander – then trading away the third rounder before taking Willie the Beavers in rd 4.
    Totally absent of logic when there were such glaring weaknesses on the O’line.

    • György Márk Kis

      Teddy’s style masked the OL problems for a while…also, Loadholt’s retirement hurt them VERY much, and Jake Long got injured the day he effectively got back into his old shape…