5 biggest free agency winners after one week

Sam Monson takes a look at the five NFL teams that have made the most of free agency thus far.

| 1 week ago
Calais Campbell

(Photo by Christian Petersen/Getty Images)

5 biggest free agency winners after one week


Free agency is still bubbling away under the surface, but the biggest moves have all been made, and all that is left is for teams to pick up the occasional scrap of quality and help for 2017.

With a week having passed since the craziness began, it’s time to take a look at the teams that have come out of the period with the most help.

“Winning” free agency doesn’t always, or even usually, translate to on-field success the following season, so it remains to be seen how the following teams put their new acquisitions to good use. On paper, though, these are the teams that have added the most quality over the past week.

1. Jacksonville Jaguars

Significant moves: Signed DI Calais Campbell, CB A.J. Bouye and S Barry Church; traded for T Branden Albert

The Jaguars have been active spenders in free agency for several years running now, and though it has yet to translate to on-field success, they are acquiring quality players along the way, and sooner or later that has to produce results. Calais Campbell is one of the league’s most formidable and disruptive interior defenders, coming off the best season of his career despite being north of 30 years old now. Campbell notched 54 total QB pressures in 2016 as well as 34 defensive stops. Only Malik Jackson posted more pressures among Jacksonville defensive linemen, and Campbell would have led the Jags with defensive stops. A.J. Bouye’s play at CB last season was excellent for Houston, earning him a huge contract, and he should pair well with second-year player Jalen Ramsey to form arguably the league’s best young tandem at CB. Barry Church was impressive in 2016 for Dallas, and even Branden Albert has proven to be a quality player in the past and battled through injury last year, so to snag him for barely any outlay is a solid move to see if he has anything left.

2. Detroit Lions

Significant moves: Signed T Ricky Wagner and G T.J. Lang

The college game—and the rise of spread offenses—doesn’t just create problems when scouting and evaluating quarterbacks and receivers, but it’s making identifying linemen a struggle, too. The Lions have decided they may be better to attack proven NFL commodities to fix their line instead, signing a pair of starting linemen in Ricky Wagner and T.J. Lang, who should form a new right side and massively upgrade the unit. Last season, Lang allowed just 10 total pressures in 13 games, less than half the figure that Larry Warford did starting at RG for Detroit. Wagner bounced back from an ugly 2015 to perform well at RT for the Ravens. He surrendered 32 total pressures over the season, being flagged just three times all year. The Lions allowed the right side of their line to walk away in the same free-agency period, but they successfully upgraded at both spots on paper, and paid less to do it than their outgoing starters received on the open market from their new teams.

3. Tampa Bay Buccaneers

Significant moves: Signed DI Chris Baker and WR DeSean Jackson

The Bucs have added a pair of extremely nice pieces to their roster without breaking the bank to do it, and at spots that have been an issue for multiple seasons now. This team has been looking for a nose tackle to play next to DT Gerald McCoy since they drafted him, and Baker is an excellent fit to do that. He earned a top-20 overall grade (82.2) in his second straight season of excellent play, and that represents a significant upgrade over Akeem Spence’s 39.2 grade from 2016. When you consider that Baker notched 42 total QB pressures—just seven fewer than McCoy—to go with his stout run defense, this looks to be a fine signing, made into one of the best-value deals in the entire free agency period. DeSean Jackson still has speed to burn and led the entire league in yards gained on deep (20-plus air yards) receptions last season (579). With Mike Evans already in place and a few receivers who have shown ability in the slot and underneath, Jackson finishes that receiving corps with the skill-set that has been missing.

4. New England Patriots

Significant moves: Signed CB Stephon Gilmore, LB Dont’a Hightower, S Duron Harmon, DI Alan Branch and DI Lawrence Guy; traded for WR Brandin Cooks

The Patriots have been one of the most active teams in free agency, and much of their best work came in the form of re-signing their own players. Key members of the Super Bowl-winning defense from 2016 were brought back in the form of LB Dont’a Hightower, interior defender Alan Branch and FS Duron Harmon. All three are versatile within New England’s defensive unit and are big players to keep around. Stephon Gilmore was their big-money splash signing. He represents a player that has outstanding skills, but maybe never quite realized his potential in Buffalo. When targeted in 2016, Gilmore allowed a passer rating of just 70.6 thanks to picking off five passes over 68 targets. The former Bill could well improve in the Patriots’ defensive scheme. Like the Lions when it comes to offensive linemen, the Patriots are prioritizing proven NFL players when it comes to receivers, and sent a first-round pick to New Orleans to acquire Brandin Cooks, a player with 17 touchdowns and 2,311 receiving yards over the past two seasons. Cooks has the blazing deep speed missing from this New England receiving corps.

5. Cleveland Browns

Significant moves: Signed G Kevin Zeitler, C J.C. Tretter, and WR Kenny Britt; traded for a second-round pick (and Brock Osweiler)

The Browns, like the Lions, invested in proven NFL talent along the offensive line. They signed G Kevin Zeitler, one of the best free agents on the market, and re-upped their own player in Joel Bitonio to form one of the league’s best guard pairings. J.C. Tretter is a player that has been good when on the field, but has never been handed the opportunity to start long-term. Last season, he started seven games for Green Bay and surrendered just eight total QB pressures; Tretter represents a huge potential upgrade for the Browns’ offensive line on a modest contract. Kenny Britt secured Cleveland at least one proven NFL-level receiver, even as Terrelle Pryor walked out of the door, but the coup of this team’s free-agent period was pulling off what amounts to the purchase of a second-round pick in 2018 by trading for Texans QB Brock Osweiler. His failure in Houston was so complete, and his contract so bad, that the Texans effectively paid Cleveland a second-round pick next year just to take his contract off their books. Cleveland entered free agency with over $100 million in cap space, so they could afford to make the move and it have zero impact on their free-agent plans. If they successfully adjust his deal and flip Osweiler to another team for even more picks, this just looks even better.

| Senior Analyst

Sam is a Senior Analyst at Pro Football Focus, as well as a contributor to ESPN.

  • crosseyedlemon

    The surprise here is that the defending champions are currently 3rd in spending during free agency. There are different ways of interpreting that I suppose. I do like that they snatched Gilmore from a division rival.

    • Fred Kruse

      I’ve read speculation that the Pats spending means Bellichick doesn’t intend to coach much longer. What do you think?

      • crosseyedlemon

        Belichick has coached for 22 years and accomplished everything a coach would want. It’s hard to imagine him staying in the game and nursing some rookie QB once Brady is gone. The spending could mean the Pats are loading up for a last hurrah or there could be legitimate weaknesses that they want to address as they prepare for the post Brady era. Robert Kraft generally isn’t viewed as an owner who throws money around frivolously.

      • Joe Doe

        I really feel like these are short term moves that may be harmful 3-5 years down the line. I completely understand the goal as being win as many with Brady and Belichick as possible, but let’s not forget that these deals could be sacrificing those years thereafter.

  • https://twitter.com/MALACHiOFCOURSE Malachi

    “(and Brock Osweiler)”, lolz

    • crosseyedlemon

      Forget Brock – you guys still have time to make Jay Cutler the big winner…lolz.

    • Leon Kalayjian

      How about elway trading a fifth rounder for osweiller and not taking a big cap hit? How does this work? Isn’t the biggest hit here with the Texans no matter what the final team actually pays? Then the broncos could just resume their maturation with the guy they originally drafted? And elway did draft him.

      • https://twitter.com/MALACHiOFCOURSE Malachi

        broncos already have 2 QBs who are better and at a fraction of the cost. no point in trading for a 16 mil salary of a player who will be cut anyway.

        by getting rid of brock’s salary the texans took a 9 mil dead cap hit, but saved another 16 mil in cash and cap. the browns are on the hook for 16mil in cash and cap, barring another trade

        • crosseyedlemon

          I think both teams managed to come out as losers on the Osweiler deal. The Texans still have a gaping hole at QB and even though their net gain cap wise is 7 mill that is not nearly enough to get a QB of any value to them.

          • Leon Kalayjian

            Is osweiller a terrible q b? The broncos drafted him second round and he played average for them in a few games. Some thought he should remain the starter over peyton cause peyton didn’t have velocity on his throws and wasnt playing that well.

            So if cleveland pays 3 mil of the 16, would broncos take him back at 13 mil and give up maybe a 4, or 5 to get him? The guy did not get a fair audition. He played a few games for Denver then one year for a new coach and system. He looked terrible at times but I keep going back to some q b s that had really bad first years. Sims, bradshaw, Eli manning…. If brock resumes with the staff he started with, he might become a serviceable q b. Q la bledsoe, flacco, Jim Everett,

          • https://twitter.com/MALACHiOFCOURSE Malachi

            the relationship with bill o’brien had grown toxic, PFT reported that at halftime of week 17 brock and o’brien got into a physical altercation that had to be broke up, and that is was the breaking point

      • crosseyedlemon

        The Browns roster is already saturated with first and second year players so why would they have any interest in acquiring a 5th round pick?

        • Leon Kalayjian

          Cause they paid a few million in cap space to pick up a 2, they just flip their house and pick up another pick without laying out any more money or cap space.