Next Man Up: 2012’s Biggest Losses and Best Subs

Peter Damilatis has tracked every NFL team's injury situation for the entire season. Here he presents the players whose absence hurt the most, and the subs who best kept their ...

| 4 years ago

Next Man Up: 2012’s Biggest Losses and Best Subs

Throughout the season we’ve chronicled how multiple teams have had their Super Bowl hopes hampered by injuries, and now the New England Patriots can be added to that list. After Aqib Talib headed to the locker room early in the AFC Championship game, Joe Flacco completed all five of his passes into backup Marquis Cole’s coverage — including the decisive touchdown that stretched the Ravens’ lead to 15 points. Patriot rookie standout Chandler Jones could manage only two snaps due to injury, and Justin Francis notched just one QB hit in 27 pass rushes in his place. When New England needed them most, the Patriots’ ‘next men up’ did not rise to the occasion.

Though injuries can help explain a team’s failures, they certainly shouldn’t excuse them. Look no further than the past two Super Bowl champions, the 2010 Green Bay Packers and 2011 New York Giants, and you’ll see two teams who were leveled by injuries but still succeeded because of their roster depth. How many analysts counted the Ravens out when Terrell Suggs tore his Achilles in the offseason, or when Lardarius Webb and Ray Lewis both suffered major injuries in Week 6? With the 2012 season nearly in the books, let’s look back at those teams who couldn’t overcome their injuries, and those backups who kept their club’s hopes alive.

The Costliest Injuries of 2012

Just Missed The Cut

Jared Gaither, OT, San Diego Chargers
In five starts for the Chargers last season, Gaither surrendered just three quarterback pressures. However, as he struggled with injuries this season, Michael Harris stepped in and earned a dreadful 86.8 Pass Blocking Efficiency. That ranked dead last among all starting tackles.

Chris Gamble, CB, Carolina Panthers
Before his injury, Gamble surrendered a reception once every 20.5 coverage snaps. Captain Munnerlyn allowed one every 9.5 coverage snaps in relief.

Clay Matthews, 3-4 OLB, Green Bay Packers
The Packers’ pass rush went on life support during four weeks without Matthews, as Dezman Moses earned just seven quarterback pressures in that span and was completely invisible at times.

Now, on with the countdown…

5. Brian Orakpo, 3-4 OLB, Washington Redskins

During the 2011 season, Brian Orakpo emerged as one of the best pass-rushers in the NFL. He earned 59 quarterback pressures and four batted passes, and his 12.2 Pass Rushing Productivity was fifth-best among all starting 3-4 outside linebackers. He picked up right where he left off this season, tallying four hurries, a sack, and a forced fumble in a game and a half. But a nagging pectoral injury returned and left the Redskins without their best pass-rusher for the rest of the season. Backup Rob Jackson played admirably in reserve, with four interceptions and just 35 yards allowed in coverage. However, he wasn’t close to the disruptive force that Orakpo was, with just 17 quarterback pressures and a 7.3 PRP. He was particularly ineffective down the stretch, with just one sack and one hurry in 69 pass rushes over his last four games, including no pressures in the Redskins’ playoff loss to the Seahawks. Washington is left to wonder if their playoff run may have lasted longer with a healthy Orakpo rushing Russell Wilson.

4. Sean Lee, ILB, Dallas Cowboys

Since he was drafted in 2010, Sean Lee has steadily developed into one of the best inside linebackers in the NFL. Seven weeks into this season, he was the Cowboys’ highest-graded defender and only NaVorro Bowman could claim a higher PFF grade at his position. Lee was an incredibly reliable run defender, with a 11.3 Run Stop Percentage and only two missed tackles in 56 attempts. However, his season was cut short in Week 8 with ligament damage to his foot, and veteran Dan Connor’s 7.5% Run Stop in reserve was a big downgrade. When Connor missed time with injuries of his own, Alex Albright stepped in and also struggled. He was partially responsible for three New Orleans touchdowns in the Cowboys’ Week 16 loss to the Saints, earning him our Worst Defensive Sub award. In Dallas’ season-ending loss to Washington, Connor and Albright tallied just two run stops on 48 combined run snaps, as Alfred Morris rushed for 200 yards and the NFC East crown. The Cowboys deserve credit for staying in the playoff hunt even without Lee, but his absence eventually caught up to them.

3. Brian Cushing, ILB, Houston Texans

You’d be hard-pressed to find a more complete inside linebacker in the NFL last season than Brian Cushing. His 13.9% Run Stop Percentage ranked third at his position, his 13.8 Pass Rushing Productivity was fifth, his 16.1 Combined Tackle Efficiency was tied for seventh, and he allowed a reception just once every 10.6 coverage snaps. A chop block from an offensive lineman tore Cushing’s ACL in Week 5, leaving the Texans with a hole in their front seven they never filled. Tim Dobbins chipped in with a solid 10.6% Run Stop Percentage, but he compiled just five quarterback pressures on the season and allowed a reception once every 7.9 coverage snaps. Houston’s linebackers rarely took advantage of having our Defensive Player of the Year on their front line. After Cushing, the highest-graded Texans’ linebacker this season earned a +0.1.

2. Percy Harvin, WR, Minnesota Vikings

Lost in the excitement over Adrian Peterson’s amazing finish, many forget that the Vikings’ All-Pro running back wasn’t Minnesota’s best player in the first half of the season. Before a Week 9 ankle injury prematurely ended his season, Percy Harvin was a legitimate MVP candidate. His 60 receptions through the first eight weeks led the league, and a stunning 529 of his 667 receiving yards came after the catch. And that’s not even mentioning his league-leading 35.9-yard average on 16 kickoff returns. Without him, the Vikings’ receiving corps was a ghost town. None of Minnesota’s other wideouts gained more than 450 yards or two touchdowns. Christian Ponder threw for 8.36 yards per attempt and a 102.8 passer rating on targets to Harvin, but 6.87 YPA and a 73.7 rating on passes to the rest of Minnesota’s wide receivers. While Harvin’s 2.59 Yards Per Route Run was one of the best marks in the league, Jarius Wright was the only Vikings receiver to have a YPRR higher than 1.05. As magical as the Vikings’ playoff run was, how much further could Minnesota have gone if they had two of the NFL’s top offensive threats on the field?

1. Jason Peters, OT, Philadelphia Eagles

The costliest injury of the 2012 NFL season actually occurred four months before training camps even opened, when Jason Peters ruptured his Achilles tendon during an offseason workout in March. He was our highest-graded offensive tackle by a significant margin in 2011, and had the best single-game performance by a left tackle. His 97.1 Pass Blocking Efficiency ranked fourth among his peers, and his +13.1 run block grade was bested only by Phil Loadholt. Philadelphia signed Demetress Bell to take Peters’ place, but the former Buffalo Bill proved to be a massive bust. Bell didn’t earn the starting job in training camp, but was called into duty after the Eagles suffered even more injuries. He mustered a -24.6 grade in just over seven games before being permanently benched. He may have had the worst sequence by an offensive lineman this season, when, in Week 9,  he committed two penalties and surrendered a sack in the span of four plays against the Saints en route to that week’s Worst Offensive Sub award. Bell surrendered 33 quarterback pressures in less than half a season, which was 12 more than Peters surrendered in all of 2011. King Dunlap steadied the ship in the second half of the season, but it was too little, too late for a team that saw it’s offensive line turn from strength to liability without Peters.

Click below to see the Best Subs of the 2012 Season

  • guest

    Harris to Gaither should be in the 5 worst subs.  They went from stellar play to literally the worst left tackle in the league, and I think its fair to say that the difference in so many of their close losses this year was having a good (or even average) left tackle vs a terrible left tackle, especially because Gaither’s presense in limited games this year somehow made the rest of the otherwise shoddy line play better.  

  • Figless

    How about Revis and Holmes?

    • Figless

      At CB you must consider the trickle down effect, the replacement, Wilson, is also being replaced in the nickel roll.

    • PFF_Pete

      Revis was considered, but his loss would’ve been felt stronger if Cromartie didn’t have a Pro Bowl-caliber season. But yes, he was on the short list for the costliest injuries.

  • Falcon

    did you forget a named Collin who subbed for a qb named Smith??

  • Matt

    Vontaze Burfict for Thomas Howard was a good one too.  Especially considering Burfict was a rookie undrafted free agent MLB filling in at WLB which he never played before in his life.  He had a half a week to transition from MLB to WLB.

    • PFF_Pete

      Absolutely. If we’d done a Top 10 of Best Subs, Burfict would definitely have been on it.

  • Darnell

    How did Jeremy Lane do?

    understanding that the sample size probably wasn’t big enough to qualify.

    • PFF_Pete

      He did admirably from Weeks 14-16, but had a poor game vs STL in Week 17. Byron Maxwell and Walter Thurmond did well in reserve. No team has more depth at CB than the Seahawks.

      • Darnell


        Given that Baltimore also has a very nice group as well and neither Sea nore Baltimore invested heavily in the CB position, what do we chalk up the success to? Uncovering hidden talents or systems that make the guys better than they would be elsewhere?

        • PFF_Pete

          A little of both. Ozzie Newsome is one of the best talent evaluators in the league, and a front office that can find Richard Sherman in the 5th round certainly knows how to identify good CBs. Also, both defenses have talent at other positions that can pick up the slack for their reserves when they come in.

  • Smartestmanalive

    Ryan Kalil?

    • PFF_Pete

       I would’ve considered Kalil a bigger loss, but he was having a subpar season even before his injury. Geoff Hangartner was certainly a downgrade, though.