Eric Winston Hits the Market. Really?

| March 13, 2012

Sometimes you really don’t see it coming. You know pretty much anything can happen in the NFL and so it’s rare for you to be genuinely taken aback. But I won’t lie. I was utterly shocked when Eric Winston was released by the Houston Texans.

One of the best right tackles in the league over the past three seasons, Winston has excelled in the Texans’ zone-blocking scheme. Outside of a few muggings, he has dominated the opposition, regardless of who he lined up against. In a league that is truly low on quality tackles, Winston was that rare breed that could be relied upon week-in, week-out.

I mean, how often is it that an offensive tackle trends worldwide on Twitter because of the respect he’s commanded among players and watchers of the game.

The Texans cut Eric Winston. To quote Vonta Leach, “Are you kidding me?”

 

Houston, We Had A Tackle …

Where do you start when it comes to explaining how good a player Winston has been for the Texans? Let’s look at his grading and how he compares to other right tackles around the league over the past three years.

Year
Pass Blocking
Run/ Screen Blocking
Overall
RT Rank
20098.4-0.811.37th
20105.52.78.85th
20117.16.311.16th

Consistently one of our higher graded right tackles, Winston fit the zone-blocking scheme perfectly with his ability to move laterally and get to the second level. His agility is a big reason why the Texans have had so much success in the run game recently. What’s more, he’s coming off a very good year with his pass protection. Not an easy feat when,  for a large portion of the year, you have a rookie quarterback that likes holding onto the ball. While it may not seem like a lot, but the extra tenth of a second T.J. Yates held onto the ball meant he did so the fifth longest of all quarterbacks. The table below demonstrates how Winston is once again among the top right tackles in the league. This time due to his Pass Blocking Efficiency which measures how much (and what type of pressure) he gives up relative to how many snaps in pass protection.

Year
Pass Blocking Snaps
Sacks
Hits
Hurries
PBE
Rank
2009637571996.24th
2010611841896.03rd
2011508722095.411th

Winston was never the dominating tackle like we’ve seen from Jake Long or Joe Thomas. Yet, his consistency year after year was virtually unrivaled.

 

Stepping Up

So, with Winston gone and, by all accounts, a contract re-working not in the cards, what does that mean for a Texans line already fighting to keep hold of its starting center and right guard? Do they think that Derek Newton (13 career snaps at tackle and seven at tight end) or Rashad Butler (who is coming off injured reserve and was terrible filling in at left tackle in 2010 with a -11.4 grade) could step in?

It seems like an incredible leap of faith, as does turning to the draft. That worked out well in the long term the last time they filled a tackle spot with a rookie, but let’s not forget the massive teething problems they had with Duane Brown. That was OK in 2008, when the team was largely transitioning, but now it’s a contender. It can’t afford a rookie coming in and disrupting a line that has got better in part because of its continuity.

For a line that could potentially lose Chris Myers and Mike Briesel, it seems odd to part with their most consistent lineman. The $6.5 million he was earning isn’t a small number, but it’s hard to believe that the free agent market doesn’t see Winston earning more than that when all is said and done. The Texans may have saved themselves some cap room and avoided investing too much money long term in the offensive line, but for a team on the cusp of something special, that may not cut it. You need only look at how the New York Jets struggled trying to replace Damien Woody when he retired and how that impacted Mark Sanchez and the run game.

 

Where to Next?

The Texans loss is about to be one teams gain. Outside of Jared Gaither (and he has his own issues), there really isn’t any proven tackle talent on the open market. Winston changes that and immediately becomes the most attractive OT available given his talent, production and age (28). There’s no such thing as a sure thing in the NFL, but tackle-hungry teams are looking at the closest thing in Winston and are likely to call his agent early and often.

The hard part about setting a market for Winston is that so many teams could use him. It’s almost easier to look at which teams wouldn’t be in the market for a right tackle (Atlanta, Baltimore, Cincinnati, Dallas, Minnesota, New England, New Orleans, Pittsburgh, San Francisco and Tennessee) than to break down all the teams that should be interested in the former Texan.

Wherever he goes, that team is going to need some cap room. I mean, if Doug Free is getting paid $8 million a year (after an admittedly good 2010) then what is Winston–a far more proven commodity, at the same age–going to command? Given how teams are creating cap room at the moment, there could be a number of teams. However, if you’re a team like the New York Jets, and you know your quarterback is unable to function when pressured, you have to make a serious run at the best tackle on the market.

Unfortunately for Mark Sanchez, the Jets won’t be the only team interested. Once the initial shock of being a cap casualty wears off, Winston should have his pick of teams to choose from.

You really can’t say it enough. Good offensive tackles like Eric Winston just don’t hit the market very often.

 

Follow Khaled on Twitter: @PFF_Khaled … and our main feed too: @ProFootbalFocus

  • tom

    As a Pat’s fan, I have watched in shock as Belichick either released or let walk top players. But, over time, I realize that when teams re-sign a top free agent talent to a big contract it offsets the balance of pay at other positions and throws their cap management out of whack for years.

    As for Houston, it is unsustainable to sign all of their top guys to big contracts (Johnson, Foster, Myers, Winston, Williams) and still have enough to go around for top backups. I don’t think it’s feasible to have a $6.5 million RT now with the salaries LT’s and G’s are demanding now. The Colts are a prime example of having a large cost structure for starters and little for backups, which I believe is why their defense was so bad, most of the cap was used up on the offense and now with no Manning, those players are being dropped.

  • rick torrey

    I understand that Winston was Kansas City today, and has not left as yet. Short of a kidnapping, the Chiefs will do all they can to sign the best available RT in free agency. Barry Richardson was rated by your own site as the worst at that position in the league.