Top 10 Rookie of the Year candidates entering Week 6

Seahawks running back Thomas Rawls sits at No. 6 after a big Week 5 performance. See who else made the list.

| 2 years ago
(AP Photo/John Froschauer)

(AP Photo/John Froschauer)

Top 10 Rookie of the Year candidates entering Week 6

Even the most optimistic Bills’ supporters didn’t expect Ronald Darby to be leading our race for Rookie of the Year after five weeks of the season. But his back-to-back stellar performances show that the cornerback is no flash in the pan, and a man that has to be taken seriously.

However, it’s very easy for rookies to hit a wall, and we’re getting to that stage of the season were the opposition has more tape—and more time—to expose a player’s flaws. Can Darby hang on to the top spot? If not, who will capitalize on the opportunity to move up?

Here are our top 10 Rookie of the Year Candidates entering Week 6:

1. Ronald Darby, CB, Bills (90.8)

Can he hang on to top spot? It’s certainly possible. Darby earned another positive grade for his efforts against Tennessee that saw him allow just four receptions all game.

2. Leonard Williams, DE, Jets (83.6)

The Jets were on bye in Week 5, so Williams sticks in the No. 2 spot. His biggest challenge in Week 6 may be logging enough snaps to move up.

3. Henry Anderson, DE, Colts (+11.9)

Five games for Anderson, each of them above +1.0; there’s no denying he’s been a tremendous value pick for the Colts, with his consistently excellent work in the run game the high point.

4. Marcus Mariota, QB, Titans (-1.4)

What do you expect out of a rookie quarterback? If you have realistic expectations, you’ll probably settle for a steadying presence and significant upgrade from what was already at the spot. Check and check.

5. Karlos Williams, HB, Bills (+3.8)

Williams drops after being sidelined against the Titans with a concussion. His playing time (injury and LeSean McCoy return-related) could see him plummet in the upcoming weeks.

6. Thomas Rawls, HB, Seahawks (+3.7)

This might be a high point for Rawls, with Marshawn Lynch set to return. However, he’s certainly made a name for himself with an excellent effort against Cincinnati.

7. Mitch Morse, C, Chiefs (+2.2)

Morse drops on this list after allowing four hurries against the Bears. That’s not really acceptable for a center at the NFL level.

8. Jordan Hicks, LB, Eagles (+4.7)

Hicks certainly wasn’t expected to play as big a part as he has for the Eagles so soon, but credit to the third-rounder for not looking out of place. A nifty blitzer who has added 10 defensive stops on the year.

9. Preston Smith, OLB, Redskins (+5.4)

Smith is becoming a bigger part of the Redskins defense, especially in sub packages, where the power he generates on stunts is something to behold. Carving out a nice little niche for himself.

10. Damarious Randall, CB, Packers (+2.1)

Randall might not be an every down player, but he is playing well enough in his limited snaps to crack the top 10. The Jests CB is definitely one to watch, but if Quintin Rollins (+3.4 on 37 snaps) keeps playing, he might struggle to be the best rookie corner on his own team.


Dropping Out

Hau’oli Kikaha, LB, Saints: A lot of Kikaha’s good work this season was undone against the Eagles with a lackluster effort.

Melvin Gordon, RB, Chargers: Gordon is in danger of fumbling his way out of contention.

Vic Beasley, DE, Falcons: Beasley is simply getting swallowed up by the better tackles in the league.


Five to Watch

Jamison Crowder, WR, Redskins: Crowder is emerging as arguably the Redskins’ go-to playmaker.

Brandon Scherff, G, Redskins: He’s not setting the league on fire, but he is holding up as well as you’d hope from a rookie.

Maxx Williams, TE, Ravens: Playing time has been an issue for Williams thus far, but in a bigger role, he’s doing nothing to dispute that he was the most complete tight end in the 2015 draft class.

Jameis Winston, QB, Buccaneers: The Jameis-coaster is trending upwards this week with an impressive showing against Jacksonville.

Todd Gurley, RB, Rams: His numbers flatter him a little, but highlight-worthy runs show what a force he can be.


  • rustymcgrady

    Why the hate on Amari Cooper?

    • ElwayIsGod7

      He’s a filthy updyke who’s not getting paid as much this year as he did in tuscaloosa.

      • Chris Simmons

        Someone needs a hug.

        Cooper should definitely be considered as he has added wins to the team already

        • Malachi

          lol. drops tho

          • Jim Winslow

            I think profootball focus over penalizes for drops.

          • Malachi

            catching the football is literally the most important part of a WR’s job, lol

          • Jim Winslow

            nah getting open consistently is more important in my book, at least the qb has a chance to throw a pass to you instead of just being out of the play.

          • Malachi

            the most open receiver who can’t catch is less valuable than the blanketed receiver who can

          • Michael Angelo

            Malachi is a hater, probably a texans fan

          • Malachi

            as if that makes sense…

            i had cooper as the number one prospect overall on 2015 class

            also, go broncos

    • josh

      Probably because he has drop issues, which on the actual reward they are gonna see yards and tds so no one is gonna care about that, so this list is dumb.

      • Malachi

        this list is for the smart people who know stats aren’t everything unlike the AP

    • Malachi


  • Jaguars28

    With better blocking, I could see Yeldon on this list. Sucks Linder is on IR though, I’d like to see Shatley play when healthy.

    • marryjason google onli!ne jobs

      Fantastic offer for all of you to make $5000 to $8000 every month….It’s easy just have a internet connection and a p.c to earn money….hgh….

      ======>>>>> Go to my discuss Account For Website Address

  • Brandon Quinlog

    no Amari Cooper? freaking what?

    • Malachi

      drop rate

      • monica Robinson

        Here is something extremely interesting that is worth to pay attention , a superb opportunity for work for those who want to utilise their free time to make some extra money using their computers… I have been working on this for last two and half years and I am earning 50-80 dollar/ hour … In the past week I have earned 13,245 dollars for almost 20 hours sitting ….

        Any special kind of skills or qualification is not required for this, just normal typing and a reliable internet connection ….

        Time limitations are not here to start work … You may work on this any time when you get some time ….

        Check it out how I’ve been doing this….view WebsiteIink on my` profile` to know how I use to work on this`


  • Malachi

    not sure why #s 1 & 2 have their ratings and 3-10 have their grades

  • nein9nein

    Delvin Breaux is the best rookie. He’s better than Darby.

    • highlander1229

      Hahaha, omg, really? That’s a good one.

    • Dexter

      Breaux looks really good and made some nice plays vs one of the best WRs in the league. I think 1 more great game like that and he’s on this list

    • Dexter

      Breaux looks really good and made some nice plays vs one of the best WRs in the league. I think 1 more great game like that and he’s on this list

  • Jason Bartels

    Yeah, I am guessing that Gurely and and Yeldon be the most valuable “skill” players at years end. They are both feature-backs without a threat behind them. Injury is the only thing stopping them from getting carries.

  • Dexter

    Thomas Rawls did a hell of a job while Lynch was gone…sucks he doesn’t have a shot at winning ROTY since beastmode is back…kinda bittersweet

  • Brandon

    Awww No Marcus Peters? Ya I know he doesn’t look good covering but 3 picks and one being taken back for a TD is arguably a lot by a rookie.