10 best free agent signings through Week 4

Eric Eager breaks down the top 10 NFL free agent signings in terms of value thus far.

| 2 years ago
Tyrod Taylor

(AP Photo/David Richard)

10 best free agent signings through Week 4

The NFL’s annual free agency period is filled with opportunity and hope for many NFL teams. While some teams use free agency liberally, and others less frequently, every NFL team is affected by players selling their services to another franchise when their contracts are up.

Some free agent acquisitions end up being home runs, while some fail miserably (check out our worst 10 free agent signings for those players). Let’s take a look at the top 10 free-agent acquisitions, in terms of value, through the first four weeks of 2015:


1. Pernell McPhee, OLB, CHI (five years, $40 million, +16.1 overall grade)

While CHI is in a rebuilding phase, they’ve started this era well with the acquisition of McPhee. While he didn’t come cheaply, he has produced at a level commensurate with the likes of Von Miller (+19.6), Justin Houston (+16.3) and Khalil Mack (+15.5) through four weeks. McPhee is tied for second amongst 3-4 OLB in QB hits (five), fifth in QB hurries (12), and has added an interception.


2. Tyrod Taylor, QB, BUF (three years, $3.35 million, +0.8 overall grade)

PFF’s 13th-highest graded quarterback, Taylor has provided momentary stability at the QB position for Buffalo. At a time where even average-to-below-average QBs are making substantial money, what’s impressive about Taylor is his contract ($1.12 million per year) has less to do with his inclusion in this list than his overall accuracy (79.3 accuracy percentage, sixth in NFL), or his performance when pressured (75.9 accuracy percentage under pressure, No. 5 in NFL).


3. James Jones, WR, GB (one year, $870,000, +6.9 grade)

Acquired prior to Week 1 to help offset an injury to Jordy Nelson, Jones has been the NFL’s fourth-best graded WR through four weeks. Playing most of GB’s offensive snaps (255/283), Jones has caught 17-of-20 targets, with a four touchdwns, zero drops, and an impressive 18.6 yards per catch.


4. Jabaal Sheard, DE, NE (two years, $11 million, +4.2)

While New England mostly lost impact players on defense during the offseason, the acquisition of Sheard registers on the other side of the ledger. Through three games (New England had a Week 4 bye), Sheard is tied for fourth among 4-3 DE in QB hurries (11), and has had two sacks and four stops.


5. Patrick Robinson, CB, SD (one year, $3 million, +6.6)

Acquired cheaply in the offseason, Robinson has been a very valuable acquisition for San Diego. Stepping in for the injured Brandon Flowers, he owns the fifth-highest grade amongst NFL cornerbacks, allowing an NFL passer rating of 34.8 on 13 targets, adding five stops, an interception, and a quarterback hit.


6. Dan Williams, NT, OAK (four years, $25 million, +10.1)

While he has graded positively every season since 2012, Williams is on pace for his best grade this season in Oakland. Solid versus the run (+7.0) and in pass coverage (+2.7), he has been a big part of Oakland’s gradual restoration of credibility. Williams has three QB hurries and six stops to this point.


7. Michael Crabtree, WR, OAK (one year, $3 million, +5.2)

Continuing with Oakland acquisitions, Crabtree is seeing a rebirth across the bay. After two years of injuries and poor play, Crabtree is starting to look like the player that graded at a +24.7 in 2012. He is currently the sixth-highest graded WR through four weeks, catching 23-of-38 targets with a touchdown and no drops.


8. Evan Mathis, G, DEN (one year $3.25 million, +3.7)

A PFF favorite for years, Mathis appears to be settling in nicely in Denver. Acquired relatively cheap in August, Mathis has been the Broncos’ highest-graded offensive lineman by a wide margin, and has rebounded well from a slow start (-3.3 and 0.5 in Weeks 1 and 2, respectively).


9. Vance Walker, DE, DEN (two years, $5 million, +4.5)

An inexpensive part of Denver’s top-ranked defense, Walker is the 16th-best 3-4 DE in the NFL through four weeks on just 137 snaps, with five quarterback hurries and four stops.


10. Nick Fairley, DT, STL (one year, $5 million, +6.0)

While playing only 65 snaps through four weeks, Fairly has the 12th-highest grade amongst DT/NT. Solid as both a pass rusher (+4.2) and run stopper (+1.7), Fairley has proven a solid complement to Aaron Donald inside, grading positively in every game to date.


Be sure to check out PFF’s worst 10 free agent signings based on value through four weeks of the season.

| Analyst

Eric Eager joined Pro Football Focus in 2015. He is currently working on a number of analytics projects, primarily focused on the NFL.

  • crosseyedlemon

    I always want to see a true free agent (ie. undrafted player) do well. The best ever of course was Donnie Shell who played in 5 pro bowls and helped the Steelers win 4 championships. He was a HOF finalist one year and certainly deserves to be inducted.

    • Kaleb Harvey

      Best ever?!? Warren Moon and Dick night train Lane were both undrafted, hall of famers, and 2 of the best players in NFL history.

      • jody

        Thanks for correcting the cross-eyed guy… My favorite was Rod Smith (Broncos)…

        • crosseyedlemon

          One of my favorites was Otis Sistrunk who was part of the crazy collection of castoffs and misfits that Al Davis put together back when the Raiders were in their glory years.

      • Vitor

        Kurt Warner, my favorite story of the league

    • King VI

      John Randle was a 7x pro-bowler and 6x All-pro. Best pass-rushing DT of all time. Way better undrafted free-agent

  • Ben

    Dan Williams is being used in pass coverage???

    • Donny Phuckstain

      I’m going to assume it refers to being on the field on passing downs, as opposed to simply rush plays

      • https://twitter.com/MALACHiOFCOURSE Malachi

        hopefully, haha. otherwise he is the best zone dropping NT ever it seems

  • https://twitter.com/MALACHiOFCOURSE Malachi

    i thought darian stewart would’ve made this list, tied for 2nd best safety grade with bam-bam kam, and was on the cheap

    • http://www.jobhome20.com Check More Info Here

      Here is a Better Option For Everyone. I have made $ 15000 This Month By Just Workiing On My Laptop. I am very Glad That Finally I have Found This Legit Company Who Give Me Work For Free. You also can make like me…uyo..

      =======>>>> Its Free For All Try it Now.

    • alexander

      if darian stewart were here would have been the 3rd ex-Raven, showing the type of organization we are. the top 2 free agents were Ravens

      • https://twitter.com/MALACHiOFCOURSE Malachi

        yup yup. i know all about ozzie and his philosophies, matter of mact my broncos are trying to be built in a similar way. we had 4 compensatory picks in the 2015 draft and expect as many or more for 2016, mr. elway has spoke fondly of ozzie newsome often in the past

  • locdog284

    best UDFA has to be kurt warner or john randle.. although romo is pretty good too

    • http://careersreport.com Christophershields

      Here is a good way how it’s possible to earn $95 an hour… After being without work for six-months , I started working over this internet-site and now I possibly could not be happier. After 3 months on my new job my income is around five thousand bucksmonth If this interests you: 1)navigate to the site link in description

    • http://careersreport.com Ann Dare

      Here is something really worth your attention , a very good opportunity for work for those who want to utilise their free time to make some extra money using their computers… I have been working on this for last two and half years and I am earning 50-80 dollar/ hour … In the past week I have earned 13,245 dollars for almost 20 hours sitting ….

      There are no special skills required just basic typing and an internet connection ….

      There are no time constraints … You may do this any time when you are free ….

      check it what I’ve been doing….Visit websiteIink on my profiIe` to see what I do`