Ratcliffe’s Post-Draft Top 50 Rookies

Jeff Ratcliffe breaks down his post-Draft top 50 rookies on offense and gives his thoughts and insights into each player.

| 3 years ago

Ratcliffe’s Post-Draft Top 50 Rookies


With the NFL Draft in the rearview mirror, we’re already in the thick of rookie draft season in dynasty leagues.

Before the draft, I ranked the top 50 rookies based on fantasy potential. With the landing spots now in place, my rankings have changed fairly significantly. These rankings will continue to shift in the coming months, but based on my present thoughts and observations, here’s my top 50 rookies for 2014:

Post-Draft Top 30 IDP Rankings

Rk Player Pos Tm Comments
1 Sammy Watkins WR BUF Not the most ideal landing spot, but he does go to an up-tempo offense. Still the best of this year’s class.
2 Mike Evans WR TB The Bucs beefed up their offense, but still have questions at QB. Evans is a beast, though, and deserves the No. 2 pick in rookie drafts.
3 Brandin Cooks WR NO Couldn’t have found a better home. Great offense + great QB = fantasy value.
4 Carlos Hyde RB SF Great landing spot in a run-heavy offense. Hyde has the skill-set to be a three-down back.
5 Odell Beckham WR NYG Should step in and see an immediate role, though you have to hope Eli rebounds.
6 Davante Adams WR GB Another fantastic landing spot. Adams has the skill set to replace James Jones’ production.
7 Cody Latimer WR DEN Rinse and repeat. Latimer could step right in to a starting gig and produce as a rookie.
8 Devonta Freeman RB ATL Outside of Hyde, Freeman is the best rookie RB fantasy prospect. Could see a significant role at some point in 2014.
9 Bishop Sankey RB TEN My guess is the hype train starts now, and he’s WAY overdrafted come August. Still, he’s a solid RB in a good situation.
10 Marqise Lee WR JAX Not the safest pick, but his future could be bright in the revitalizing Jags offense.
11 Jordan Matthews WR PHI Size, speed, and Chip Kelly’s offense. I may actually be undervaluing Matthews at this spot.
12 Kelvin Benjamin WR CAR Likewise, I may be undervaluing Benjamin a tad, but he’s a one-hit wonder with suspect hands. That said, he’s the only show in town.
13 Eric Ebron TE DET Likely to be gone by this point. I’m not sold that Ebron is a future elite fantasy TE.
14 Tre Mason RB SL Good fit behind an solid offensive line, but almost guaranteed to be in an RBBC with Zac Stacy.
15 Johnny Manziel QB CLV Would have been a spot or two higher but the Gordon situation hurts. Still, I’m buying Manziel’s long-term value.
16 Allen Robinson WR JAX Not crazy about his immediate fantasy value, but Robinson has an intriguing long-term fantasy profile.
17 Isaiah Crowell RB CLV Don’t let the UDFA fool you. Crowell has a ton of talent, and has a good opportunity in Cleveland.
18 Martavis Bryant WR PIT A surprise draft drop for Bryant, but he has a good QB and offers a lot of upside.
19 Donte Moncrief WR IND High-ceiling receiver with the best young QB in the league. Not the most consistent, but you’re drafting for upside.
20 Jeremy Hill RB CIN The Law Firm 2.0? Not quite. Hill’s more talented, but that’s the role Hill will get with the Bengals.
21 Teddy Bridgewater QB MIN He’s a classic high-floor, low-ceiling fantasy quarterback. I’d prefer him as roster depth in dynasty leagues.
22 Blake Bortles QB JAX The third overall pick didn’t change anything. He’s still my third QB in this crop.
23 Jace Amaro TE NYJ Not crazy about the prospects of Amaro in a Jets uniform, but he’s still a monster and should produce decent numbers.
24 Terrance West RB CLV The ideal one-cut back for Kyle Shanahan. My concern is whether he can hack it against tougher competition.
25 Lache Seastrunk RB WSH “Lake” isn’t in line for a feature role, but he’s still a home run hitter. You’re picking him for upside.
26 Austin Sefarian-Jenkins TE TB Lacks athleticism, but he’s in a great spot with a basketball team in Tampa.
27 Paul Richardson WR SEA Goes to a run-heavy offense where he’s likely to see a limited role early in his career.
28 Jarvis Landry WR MIA Has PPR appeal in an offense that needs viable weapons for Ryan Tannehill.
29 Andre Williams RB NYG Won’t see much action in year one, but has the chance for a significant role if Rashad Jennings doesn’t pan out.
30 Storm Johnson RB JAX Great landing spot for Johnson. Gets paired up with Bortles again on a shallow depth chart.
31 Ka’Deem Carey RB CHI Matt Forte’s handcuff will not see much action unless there’s an injury to Forte.
32 Charles Sims RB TB See above. In Tampa, Sims is stepping into a backup role for Doug Martin.
33 Jeff Janis WR GB Couldn’t have landed in a better spot. He’s unproven, but his freakish athleticism bodes positively.
34 Josh Huff WR PHI He knows Chip Kelly’s system and could be a solid producer. But that’s not likely to come until 2015.
35 Bruce Ellington WR SF Lands in a run-heavy offense, which isn’t ideal for the speedy little receiver.
36 Jared Abbrederis WR GB Has an intriguing profile, but his history of concussions makes Abbrederis a risky pick.
37 James White RB NE BB added another horse to his stable. You never know with Pats running backs.
38 Derek Carr QB OAK Big arm, but he sees more ghosts than Blaine Gabbert. There’s a gap between him and the top 3 QBs in this class.
39 Marion Grice RB SD Joins a crowded house in San Diego, and isn’t likely to see many snaps in 2014.
40 Brandon Coleman WR NO An excellent landing spot for the big receiver who has a similar fantasy profile to Marques Colston.
41 Logan Thomas QB ARI One of the more surprising Day 3 picks. He’s a big boy with a high ceiling, though it could take time to see dividends.
42 David Fluellen RB PHI He’s in a run-heavy offense with opportunity now that Bryce Brown is in Buffalo.
43 Troy Niklas TE ARZ I love his game tape, but don’t like his landing spot. Arizona doesn’t use the TE much.
44 Lorenzo Taliaferro RB BLT Big back out of Coastal Carolina doesn’t have much wiggle, but the Ravens’ shaky RB situation gives him sleeper appeal.
45 Robert Herron WR TB Solid receiver, but it’s tough to see him making much of an impact with the weapons in Tampa.
46 Kevin Norwood WR SEA Like I said about Richardson, the run-heavy offense limits Norwood’s fantasy potential.
47 De’Anthony Thomas RB KC Not the best pure football player, but has a McCluster skill set in Andy Reid’s offense.
48 Jimmy Garoppolo QB NE With Tom Brady’s contract fully guaranteed through 2017, it’s tough to see Garoppolo getting a shot any time soon.
49 Jerick McKinnon RB MIN Likely to be Adrian Peterson’s backup. We’ve seen production from that guy any time AP is injured.
50 James Wilder RB CIN Monster of a back who is intriguing, but doesn’t have a great chance of panning out.


Editor’s Note: Be sure to check out our new Mock and Companion Draft Tool. Utilizing our updated player projections, run a quick mock draft and see where this year’s crop of free agents are coming off the board in early fantasy football drafts.

Jeff Ratcliffe is the Assistant Managing Editor and resident IDP maven of PFF Fantasy. 

mzl.wsyubhrgFollow Jeff           fb_icon_325x325Like Jeff           imagesRead Jeff


| Director of Fantasy

Jeff Ratcliffe is the Director of Fantasy at Pro Football Focus. He produces all of our projections and is 2016's second-most-accurate ranker in the fantasy industry. Jeff also is the host of our show on SiriusXM fantasy sports radio and is one of the main hosts of our Fantasy Slant podcast.

Comments are closed.