Why Browns must address their run defense problem

After a heartbreaking loss on MNF, John Breitenbach explains why Cleveland's run defense needs immediate attention.

| 2 years ago
(AP Photo/Brad Penner)

(AP Photo/Brad Penner)

Why Browns must address their run defense problem

Cleveland fell to 2-9 with their loss to the Ravens on Monday Night Football. The issues at quarterback are well-documented, but one persistent issue over the past few years has been the run defense. The Browns have ranked near the bottom of the league against the rush over the past few seasons. A number of offseason additions have failed to pay off. The Browns have acquired a number of players, especially at five-technique, whose priority was rushing the passer, rather than defending the run.

Season Run defense league rank
2013 16th
2014 20th
2015 31st

To be fair, Cleveland made attempts to address the issue in this year’s draft by adding NT Danny Shelton (-4.3) in the first round. Although he’s had a steady start to his NFL career, he’s likely to improve the Browns’ run defense in the coming years.

Shelton finished seventh overall against the run in 2014 amongst college defensive interiors. However, the Browns decided to go after another pass rusher on the defensive line with their third-round pick, adding Xavier Cooper from Washington State. He’s really struggled this season, recording a -14.7 grade overall, and has found NFL life tough against the run, in particular, where he’s recorded a -9.4 grade in just 106 snaps. Cooper’s struggles are perhaps unsurprising, considering he graded as only our 221st college interior defender against the run.

The strategy of adding predominantly pass-rushing 3-4 defensive ends extends to free agency, also. Randy Starks was outstanding for the Dolphins in 2013, but he struggled at the point of attack last year. Despite recording a -6.6 run defense grade, the Browns added him anyway. Although he’s done a decent job this year (+1.0), he’s not capable of covering for the deficiencies of players around him. Starks has just one positively-graded season against the run since 2009.

The same arguments can be made about the signing of Desmond Bryant. He made a name for himself as a pass rush specialist with the Raiders in 2012, recording a +14.0 grade in that facet of his play. However, he graded negatively against the run (-1.0). Since moving to Cleveland, he has a -10.1 grade in run defense, even if he’s shown improvement this year (+1.4).

Overall the Browns’ strategy for developing a strong run defending unit appears muddled. They ask their defensive lineman to two-gap and take on double teams, but then add players who are better at pushing the pocket. The struggle of the run defense is not only the responsibility of the defensive line—the linebackers and secondary are culpable too—but it’s a priority for the men up front. Considering their personnel are more adept at rushing the passer, it’s no surprise the Browns continue to get gashed on the ground.

| Analyst

John joined the PFF team in 2008, providing focused analysis on the NFL draft, team-building strategies, and positional value.

  • crosseyedlemon

    The Browns haven’t had a dominant run defense since the days when Walter Johnson and Jerry Sherk were making pro bowl appearances.

    • http://ReportMom.com wilma scott

      Google gives you a great opportunity to earn

      98652$/WEEk at your home .If you

      are some intelligent you make many more Dollars.I am

      also earning many more, my relatives wondered to see how i settle my

      Life in few days thank GOD to you for this…You can also make cash i

      never tell a lie you should check this I am sure you shocked to see

      this amazing offer…I’m Loving it!!!! ☻ ▼ ▼ ▼


      »»»»»»»»» Go to my Account For WE


  • Zack23

    So basically square pegs in round holes and lack of flexibility from coach/scheme. That goes straight to coaching staff, GM, and owner.

    • crosseyedlemon

      Actually I was thinking that too much flexibility has been the Browns problem over the years. They flip flop from one approach to another always trying to copy some other teams success instead of establishing their own identity. You need stability to become a winning franchise and the Browns seem to always have a revolving door of GMs and coaches.