Top 10 NFL rookies entering Week 6

Dallas Cowboys running back Ezekiel Elliott sits at No. 7 in our race for Rookie of the Year entering Week 6.

| 9 months ago
Cowboys RB Ezekiel Elliott

(Photo by Ronald Martinez/Getty Images)

Top 10 NFL rookies entering Week 6

With each passing week, we see more and more rookies getting legitimate playing time, and many have answered the call. This week, four new faces grace our top 10, though the top of the list remains relatively unchanged, as five guys have legitimately separated themselves from the rest of the pack at this point.

1. Carson Wentz, QB, Eagles

Carson Wentz finally threw an interception in the Eagles’ first loss of the season, but once again, the good seemed to outweigh the bad. Wentz had a couple of other ugly, off-target throws, but those have been very rare exceptions until this point. The Eagles’ quarterback would still have a completion percentage of 60.0 on the year even if you threw out every pass he’s thrown under 10 yards downfield. Through four games, at least, we’re witnessing something truly special from this rookie.

2. Dak Prescott, QB, Cowboys

With each passing week, Dak Prescott goes from a nice fill-in to possibly still the starter when Tony Romo returns. If you’re looking for obvious flaws to point out in the rookie’s, game they are few and far between at this point. The biggest knock would have to be his deep passing, where he’s only been accurate on two of nine attempts 20+ yards downfield. That has been offset, though, by his impeccable decision-making, as Prescott’s one turnover-worthy throw is the fewest of any starter in the league.

3. Rashard Robinson, CB, 49ers

Forget rookies—out of all of the cornerbacks in the NFL, no one has given up fewer yards per coverage snap than Rashard Robinson (0.33). In 94 snaps, he’s been targeted nine times and allowed a grand total of 31 yards on four receptions. Those numbers are out of this world for a first-year DB. He finally moved into a starting role the past two weeks, and has shown no signs of slowing down.

4. Jack Conklin, RT, Titans

Jack Conklin finally started to show those pass-protection flaws that everyone was worried about coming out of Michigan State. Against Cameron Wake, the Tennessee right tackle couldn’t quite adjust to his speed, resulting in Conklin’s lowest grade of the season, albeit still only slightly-below average. For the year, Conklin is the third-highest graded right tackle in the NFL.

5. Cody Whitehair, C, Bears

Yet another rookie where you can disregard his inexperience, Whitehair is already playing at a level that’s among the best centers in the NFL. He’s now the sixth-highest graded center in the league after dominating the Colts’ front on Sunday. On runs directly through the A-gaps this year, Bears running backs are averaging 6.8 yards per carry.

6. Brian Poole, CB, Falcons

Undrafted free agents, whether consciously or subconsciously, never seem to get the benefit of the doubt in the arena of public perception. When are they going to justify everyone’s preconceived notions of their talent? For Poole, it’s looking like that day may not come this year. He’s the Falcons second-highest graded corner behind Desmond Trufant, and is among the top 10 cornerbacks league-wide in yards per coverage snap surrendered.

7. Ezekiel Elliott, RB, Cowboys

Almost the unanimous preseason favorite to win Rookie of the Year, Elliott got off to a slow start before coming on strong with 412 rushing yards over the past three weeks. His vision and explosiveness are everything people thought they’d be coming out of Ohio State. This weekend’s matchup against the Packers’ No. 1-ranked run defense should be a nice test for the rookie.

8. Tavon Young, CB, Ravens

Tavon Young was playing in sub-packages the first four weeks of the season before finally getting the start against Washington, where he maintained his high level of play. His 0.62 yards per coverage snap are better than the likes of Seahawks CB Richard Sherman and Broncos CB Chris Harris Jr. at this point.

9. Kyler Fackrell, OLB, Packers

Kyler Fackrell continues to be an effective third-down pass-rusher, and after recording his highest-graded game of the season against the Giants, the former Utah State standout finally makes this list. Fackrell’s 15.1 pass-rushing productivity mark on 44 pass-rushing snaps puts him at fifth among qualifying outside linebackers—and only 1.5 points behind Broncos OLB Von Miller.

10. Joey Bosa, DE/OLB, Chargers

It only took Joey Bosa 27 snaps in his NFL debut to put up the highest-graded game from any rookie defensive lineman this season. The grade wasn’t earned against a less-talented opponent, either, as he took Raiders veteran LT Donald Penn to task multiple times. Bosa recorded two sacks, a hit, and four pressures in 20 pass-rushing snaps. If that becomes the norm from here on out, he’ll be challenging for a top-three spot on this list sooner rather than later.

| Senior Analyst

Mike is a Senior Analyst at Pro Football Focus. His work has also been featured on The Washington Post, ESPN Insider, and 120 Sports.

  • Jacob M. Lundeen

    As a 49ers fan, my excitement for Robinson is growing, I’m the first to admit that I was not big on him when he drafted him and didn’t expect much. That being said, I am a little concerned with what the coaching staff might do when Ward comes back. Ward and Robinson are our best two corners, but Brock has been the starter for a couple of years now, and the CS might continue to start him over Robinson because he is a vet.

    • Cheyne Johnson

      Our nickle back Chris Davis went on IR last week. They’ll probably move Ward to nickel when he’s healthy.

  • Samuel Mazzini

    Ozzie Newsome is the best talent evaluator since Bill Walsh.

    • DaStrongSKRAWN

      Fact! Seahawks’ guy & Elway are right after.

      • Samuel Mazzini

        Elway yes,Schneider no.

        • DaStrongSKRAWN

          Disagree. Seahawks have gotten late round and early round talent in drafts.

          • Samuel Mazzini

            There’s no denying that but he’ll have to do it over a protracted period of time while garnering multiple Champions before he solidifies his spot amongst the elite.

          • Samuel Mazzini


          • Samuel Mazzini


        • SkolBro

          No love for the guy that taught Schneider, Reggie McKenzie and John Dorsey?

          No love for Ted Thompson? Dude finds late round/undrafted gems every year.

          • Samuel Mazzini

            Borderline ,he’s had some dry spells,he’s relegated to the second tier.

  • dlund6cutler

    Cody Whitehair and Jordan Howard are doing great right now.. Can’t say the same about Floyd.

    • crosseyedlemon

      I think more fans would rather watch Pink Floyd than Leonard Floyd.

  • Daniel Varnadore

    Atlanta’s rookies are looking very solid up to this point, Keanu, Deion, Hooper and Poole…cant wait to see Campbell back in action. #RiseUp

  • kstep15

    Well done Kyler, proud of ya!!