NO-NYG grades: Free-agent addition Janoris Jenkins earns highest grade in Giants’ win

Highest-graded players and top takeaways from the Giants' 16-13 win over the Saints in Week 2.

| 9 months ago
Giants CB Janoris Jenkins

(Photo by Elsa/Getty Images)

NO-NYG grades: Free-agent addition Janoris Jenkins earns highest grade in Giants’ win

New York Giants 16, New Orleans Saints 13

Here are the top takeaways and highest-graded players from New York’s 16-13 win at home over the Saints.

New Orleans Saints

Quarterback grade: Drew Brees, 74.1

Drew Brees perfect between the numbers in losing effort

It wasn’t quite the shootout this matchup proved to be in 2015, but Drew Brees still managed 46 dropbacks in a losing effort to the Giants. Brees had trouble connecting with receivers outside the numbers, completing just 2-of-10 passes thrown over 10 yards in the air and outside the numbers. But for whatever struggles he faced in that area, he was lethal between the numbers, particularly in the intermediate range (10-19 yards), where he completed all five of his attempts for 88 yards and his lone touchdown.

Top offensive grades

C Max Unger, 80.5

FB John Kuhn, 79.8

RT Zach Strief, 78.0

G Andrus Peat, 76.8

G Jahri Evans, 74.7

Free-agent addition Coby Fleener struggles for the second week in a row

For as much as the Saints spent on former Colts tight end Coby Fleener, they’ve received poor returns so far on the investment. Fleener tied for the team lead with eight targets, yet only caught two passes, dropping a well-placed ball on a corner route against Giants S Landon Collins early in the first quarter. He’s notched just three catches for 35 yards through two weeks, despite seeing 12 targets. He’ll have to increase his production, or else figures to be another poor free-agent signing for New Orleans.

Coby Fleener’s receiving chart through Week 2

Coby Fleener receiving chart

Top defensive grades

LB Craig Robertson, 84.0

DE Cameron Jordan, 83.6

S Jarius Byrd, 80.9

CB Ken Crawley, 77.3

S Vonn Bell, 77.2

LB Craig Robertson earns Saints’ top Week 2 grade

Linebacker Craig Robertson followed up an average Week 1 with a team-high grade against the Giants. Seven of his 12 tackles counted as defensive stops, although he failed to convert any of his nine rushes into pressure. DE Cameron Jordan also bounced back from a rough opener, grading above-average in both facets with two pressures to go with two stops, and several other positive plays at the point of attack in run defense.

On the back end, the Saints did an commendable job without Delvin Breaux, and with P.J Williams limited to just nine snaps. Before Williams went out, he compiled a stop and pass defense. Ken Crawley gave up the game-winning jump ball to WR Victor Cruz, but graded well otherwise, with a pass defense and just three other receptions allowed in more than 40 coverage snaps. The task of shadowing Odell Beckham Jr. went to Sterling Moore (34.3 overall grade), who had the worst game of the group, with multiple coverage penalties and six receptions allowed on 10 targets.

New York Giants

Quarterback grade: Eli Manning, 84.9

Impressive outing from Eli Manning in low-scoring victory

This was a solid performance from Eli Manning, who was nearly perfect when throwing between the numbers, going 17-for-18 there, several times taking advantage of the Saints’ linebackers biting hard on play action. As expected, he faced very little pressure against a pass-rush that had one of the league’s lower pressure rates throughout the preseason and in Week 1. The Saints reached Manning on just 18.2 percent of his dropbacks, although his quick release (2.30 average time to attempt) helped nullify the rush at times.

Among his best throws was a dime to Odell Beckham Jr. that was dropped on the team’s final drive. On the next play, though, he gave CB Ken Crawley a shot on a jump ball to Victor Cruz, which was one of the few times Manning put the ball at risk over 41 aimed attempts.

Eli Manning passing under pressure versus Saints

Eli Manning versus Saints

Top offensive grades

QB Eli Manning, 84.9

WR Sterling Shepard, 78.6

RG John Jerry, 78.5

C Weston Richburg, 73.2

LT Ereck Flowers, 72.7

Rookie WR Sterling Shepard shines with increased workload

Right tackle Marshall Newhouse was one of the league’s highest-graded tackles in Week 1, but struggled against the Saints, with two sacks and two hurries surrendered in 41 pass-blocking snaps (although his second sack was a fairly difficult stunt pickup). Otherwise, the team’s offensive line had a solid game, particularly John Jerry, who made several positive blocks in the run and screen game.

Behind Manning, the second-highest grade on the Giants’ offense went to rookie WR Sterling Shepard, who saw an increase from his Week 1 workload, catching all eight targets for 117 yards and a 118.8 passer rating. Those catches came against five different defenders in primary coverage.

Top defensive grades

CB Janoris Jenkins, 87.7

DE Jason Pierre-Paul, 82.0

LB Jonathan Casillas, 80.9

CB Leon Hall, 79.3

DT Johnathan Hankins, 78.4

CB Janoris Jenkins finishes second with three defensive stops

Corners who make a lot of tackles are often the ones giving up a lot of catches, and while Jenkins allowed seven completions into his coverage, not one of those catches exceeded 15 yards. Excelling in the Giants’ defense, Jenkins surrendered just 49 yards on a team-high 10 targets, and his three defensive stops trailed only Landon Collins. While his near-interception of Drew Brees was an outstanding break on the ball, his recovery of the blocked field goal and subsequent touchdown are what pushed the Giants over the Saints in the end.

PFF Game-Ball Winner: CB Janoris Jenkins, 87.7

  • crosseyedlemon

    The Giants were more dominate than the score would indicate but they will be hard pressed to win future games if they keep spotting opponents a 3 turnover edge.

    • Gordon Blewis

      There’s no reason to believe that they will keep spotting opponents a three turnover edge.

  • KMax

    Terrific game from Eli Manning but fantasy football mouthbreathers will cry about zero tds and their stupid fantasy points. He was patient and poised as his offense was killing drive after drive after drive. Defense kept them in it and Brees reined in.

    But how the hell does Beckham keep dropping the easiest passes that are sure touchdowns? Very next play, Eli sees Cruz one on one against the rookie and went for the jugular. It paid off. These are things that don’t show up on stats but what makes Eli Manning’s fans defend him so fiercely. He’s got cojones.

    • nonono

      Based on the article, it appears that Eli was given a negative grade for that completed pass to Cruz

      • AC2

        Yeah that’s the point. What PFF does is very limited. It was a great throw and great catch.

      • Derrik A Riullano

        They “LITERALLY” hate Eli Manning. Check last week vs Dak and the Cowboys. Crazy! I first realized this last year when the Giants played the Bills and Eli threw 3TDs and got a negative rating. Russell Wilson played the next night and had 3 fumbles and no TDs and got a better ranking than Eli.

        • Will

          Glancing at their grades across the games, PFF gave Eli the 4th highest QB grade in the league this week despite a not-exactly-dominant final stat line against a defense that seems like one of the worst in the NFL and was missing its top 2 CBs…
          I’ve felt the Eli hate from this site before but this is weird time to complain about it.

          • mormonrock124

            What wasn’t dominant about his stat line? Lack of TD passes wasn’t the result of Eli but dropped passes. Larry Donnell and Odell dropped TD passes in this game. He completed 78% of his passes a high % going past 15 yds, typically this gets you a high grade. The Giants offense put up over 400 yds of offense w/o a running game today.

  • Mighty Whig

    incredibly, some love for Eli in this posting. Is PFF getting the message?

    • al4000

      If there’s a message, they better hear it. The “hate” for Eli Manning on PFF lately has been over the top and it makes everyone question their bias. To be fair, it stemmed mostly from an idiotic article in the off season where the writer insisted Eli was in decline. Then, where they ranked him sent the absurdity and outcry over the top.

      Even calling it a solid performance is weak. 78% completion where 7 of 9 passes were straight drops is a hell of a lot more than “solid”.

      • Mighty Whig

        I read PPF for its unintentional entertainment value. For good analysis on the Giants, read Paul Schwartz in the NYP.