KC-NYJ grades: Chiefs defense has its way with Jets, Fitzpatrick

The Jets quarterback threw six interceptions in a losing effort Sunday.

| 9 months ago
(Jamie Squire/Getty Images)

(Jamie Squire/Getty Images)

KC-NYJ grades: Chiefs defense has its way with Jets, Fitzpatrick

Kansas City Chiefs 24, New York Jets 3

Here are the biggest takeaways and highest-graded players from the Chiefs’ win over the Jets:

Kansas City Chiefs

Quarterback gradeAlex Smith, 82.5

It was the typical “Alex Smith, game manager” game as he was able to connect on just one pass over 10 yards — he gained just 17 yards on 3 targets between 10 and 19 yards and missed on all three passes over 20 yards. The Jets left the middle of the field underneath open and Smith was incredibly efficient, going 12-of-12 for 162 yards and 1 TD when targeting that area. When kept clean, Smith was deadly, completing 22-of-25 for 211 yards and 1 TD.


Top offensive grades:

QB Alex Smith, 82.5
TE Travis Kelce, 81.5
RT Mitchell Schwartz, 74.6
WR Chris Conley, 71.7
C Mitch Morse, 68.1

Offensive line roughed up despite win

The notion that games are won in trenches didn’t hold true in this game, as the Chiefs’ offensive line was dominated all game long against the strong Jets front. RT Mitchell Schwartz was the lone bright spot on the line as Schwartz allowed just 1 pressure all game while holding his own as a run blocker. LT Eric Fisher (35.8) struggled to block do-everything-man DE Sheldon Richardson as he allowed a sack, a hit and a hurry.

Top defensive grades:

ILB Derrick Johnson, 95.7
CB Marcus Peters, 87.5
S Eric Berry, 85.3
S Daniel Sorensen, 83.2
DT Dontari Poe, 80.9

Derrick Johnson leads a strong defense

One of the Chiefs’ veteran re-signings this offseason, Derrick Johnson repaid Kansas City’s investment in him with an excellent performance against the Jets. He nabbed one of Ryan Fitzpatrick’s many interceptions, returning it for a touchdown, and forced another by undercutting a slant in the red zone and popping it up to a teammate. He led the team with five defensive stops (no other Chief had more than two) and 10 total tackles. Johnson surrendered just 20 yards from seven targets, showing that he’s one of the league’s few linebackers who seems to have little trouble holding up in man coverage against running backs.

New York Jets

Quarterback grade: Ryan Fitzpatrick, 17.1

Fitzpatrick falls back down to earth

Just 10 days after a phenomenal outing in Buffalo, Fitzpatrick reminded the Jets why they were so hesitant to re-sign him this past offseason. His six interceptions torpedoed New York’s chances in this game, none worse than the pick-six thrown to Derrick Johnson that all but ended the game. While a couple of his interceptions were deflections with unfortunate bounces, one of those hit Johnson square in the chest before ricocheting to a teammate, and he had several others that he was lucky weren’t picked. Aside from those six interceptions, Fitz-travesty’s ball placement was inconsistent at best, routinely leaving balls slightly off target, allowing the Chiefs to notch four additional pass deflections.

Top offensive grades:

HB Matt Forte, 79.0
LT Ryan Clady, 73.1
RT Brent Qvale, 72.6
LG James Carpenter, 67.9
RG Brian Winters, 61.6

Forte is lone bright spot on offense

Many questioned if Forte’s age would catch up with him once he left the Windy City, but the 30-year-old back has played well as the Jets’ feature back thus far. With the highest grade on New York’s offense, he’s climbed to second overall (80.1) in our halfback grades, behind only David Johnson. He added two missed tackles on the ground in this game to bring his total to six on the year, and routinely made cuts that helped him earn more on the ground than what was provided for him by the line.

Top defensive grades:

DI Leonard Williams, 83.2
DI Muhammad Wilkerson, 82.9
DI Sheldon Richardson, 81.5
CB Buster Skrine, 80.5
DI Steve McLendon, 80.2

Dominant defensive line doesn’t result in victory

The Jets have arguably the best defensive line in the NFL and they showed exactly why, as the Chiefs offensive line couldn’t block the trio of Leonard Williams, Sheldon Richardson and Muhammad Wilkerson. Williams had 1 sack, 3 hurries and 3 stops; Richardson 1 sack, 1 hurry, and 4 stops; and Wilkerson 1 hit, 1 hurry, and 4 stops. They continually pushed the point of attack in the run game and harassed the offensive line in the pass game. Their efforts were spoiled by the play of the Jets’ offense.

PFF Game-Ball Winner: Chiefs LB Derrick Johnson

PFF’s player grading process includes multiple reviews, which may change the grade initially published in order to increase its accuracy. Learn more about how we grade and access grades for every player through each week of the NFL season by subscribing to Player Grades.

| Analyst

John is an analyst for Pro Football Focus and former safety for the University of Kansas Jayhawks (2004–2006).

  • AJ

    I like these new grades on the normalized 0-100 scale, but I also liked the raw grades that used to be shown (the ones that used 0.0 as average then went positive or negative from there).

    I’d like to know how Fitzpatrick performed in this game compared to the worst games ever graded for a QB.

    • Brandon Chester

      The worst game ever recorded by a QB was conveniently the Denver versus KC match up when Manning was benched.

    • Brandon Chester

      Great question that I had to ask. Fitz now has the worst PFF grade by any QB. The second worst was Manning versus KC last year. PFF writer Sam confirmed it for me.

      • https://twitter.com/MALACHiOFCOURSE Malachi

        the bummer for fitzy is he can’t say he had a torn plantar fascia and a rib injury heading into KC as well

        • Brandon Chester

          Ya but that’s what old man Manning gets for putting his records before the good of the team.

          • https://twitter.com/MALACHiOFCOURSE Malachi

            fair enough, albeit coach kubes can be heard mic’d up in that game saying it’s his fault and the he should’ve known better because manning couldn’t even practice at all that week due to said injuries

          • Brandon Chester

            Well to Manning’s defense he made the Broncos relevant from 2012-14. So it was Denvers obligation to allow him to break those records. I don’t think Denver would be the team they are today without the help of Manning. I’ve always said Oz should of started that game. It would at least of been competitive.

          • https://twitter.com/MALACHiOFCOURSE Malachi

            those same chiefs started a ten game win streak in that game, so it’s not like it was a fluke either. the broncos were relevant before manning ever came on board too, they had knocked off the number 1 defense in the playoffs the year before, with some QB who i shall not name. lol

  • crosseyedlemon

    Doesn’t a QB earn a higher grade than 17.1 by simply spiking the ball into the ground each snap? The performance by the Chiefs hasn’t convinced me they are ready to challenge the Broncos for a division crown but at least they can use this game as a starting point to work out some issues they still have.

  • E

    isn’t PFF supposed to take things into context?? all they say is Alex missed on all three passes over 20 yards. they fail to mention that all three hit the receivers in the hands 2 were dropped and the other the receiver failed to stay in bounds. whatever what a joke.