Buffalo Bills head coach Rex Ryan has named EJ Manuel the starter for Saturday’s game against Pittsburgh, but it’s anyone’s guess if this means Manuel is the front-runner for the Week 1 starting gig, as the Bills have had a different starter for each preseason game. It seems Rex is giving each QB game-time reps with the first team before making a final decision.
While Matt Cassel looks like he is out of the race by virtue of being a below-average NFL QB his entire career, Tyrod Taylor and Manuel are works in progress with unknown potential.
Taylor was given the start against Cleveland and didn’t disappoint against a stout Browns defense. While he was at fault for a sack, Taylor was poised when facing pressure overall, just as he was against Carolina. He actually graded better against pressure than he did without it.
Manuel showed some late-game heroics in Cleveland, as he completed a 4th-and-long TD pass with under two minutes left in the game. While Manuel has graded better overall and has posted a better QB rating than Taylor, he has done so against second-, third-, and fourth-string players, whereas Taylor has played primarily against starters and second-stringers.
Manuel has performed worse when facing pressure, especially against the Browns, where he was sacked three times, posted a 68.8 QB rating, and graded at -0.9.
We’ll see how he does in a starting role against the Steelers. It will likely determine who starts Week 1 versus the Colts.