CAR-NO Grades: Panthers fend off Saints, remain undefeated

The top takeaways and highest-graded players from the Panthers’ 41-38 win over the Saints.

| 2 years ago
(AP Photo/Mike McCarn)

(AP Photo/Mike McCarn)

CAR-NO Grades: Panthers fend off Saints, remain undefeated

Here are the top takeaways and highest-graded players from the Panthers’ 41-38 win over the Saints.

Carolina Panthers

– QB Cam Newton (+8.0) earned his best grade of the season, finishing with 380 combined passing and rushing yards. Newton was 10 of 14 for 154 yards, 2 touchdowns and a 147 QB Rating under pressure, and was nearly perfect after an early interception to Saints CB Delvin Breaux. This game did nothing but strengthen Newton’s case for NFL MVP, especially after his game-winning 75-yard touchdown drive (63 passing yards, 7 rushing yards) that kept the Panthers undefeated.

– All four of Carolina’s starting defensive linemen earned positive grades in this game, led by veteran DE Charles Johnson (+2.3). The team combined for a +6.0 pass rushing grade, and DT Kawann Short recorded six total pressures. Short has been dominant both as a pass rusher and in run defense this season, and currently ranks 5th of 67 qualifying NFL defensive tackles with a +34.6 overall grade.

– HB Jonathan Stewart (+0.5) made the best of the mediocre run blocking in front of him (-3.4 team run blocking grade), forcing six missed tackles and earning 54 of his 82 rushing yards after contact. Led by Stewart and Newton, the Panthers totaled 175 rushing yards at 5.1 yards per carry, even though the Saints’ front seven consistently won their matchups against Carolina’s offensive line.

Top performers:

QB Cam Newton (+8.0)
DE Charles Johnson (+2.3)
DT Kawann Short (+2.1)
DE Jared Allen (+1.8)
LB Thomas Davis (+1.5)

New Orleans Saints

– Drew Brees (+1.4) had a productive game overall, but was affected by Carolina’s pass rush (+2.0 grade with a clean pocket, -1.5 grade under pressure). The Saints finished with a -6.6 team pass protection grade, and Brees was pressured on 18 of his 45 drop-backs. Brees’ QB Rating dropped from 112.8 to 31.6 when the Panthers sent more than four pass rushers. HB C.J. Spiller played just five snaps on offense, and appeared to run the wrong route on his only target of the day.

– New Orleans’ defensive front seven was impressive against the run, as six players earned green grades in that area. LB Stephone Anthony led the way with four stops and a +3.1 run defense grade, and four other players each recorded three run stops. DT Kevin Williams earned a season-best +4.5 overall grade with two run stops and six pressures. Williams has quietly enjoyed an excellent season, and currently ranks 12th of 67 NFL defensive tackles with a +12.8 season grade.

– The Saints finished with a -7.0 team pass coverage grade, and were unable to slow down the Panthers’ passing attack after star CB Delvin Breaux (+2.8) left the game due to injury. CB Brandon Browner earned a team-worst -4.9 grade after allowing a pair of touchdowns and committing three penalties. With twenty penalties in just 12 games, Browner already holds the record for the most penalties in a season of any cornerback in the PFF era (2007-present). Linebackers Stephone Anthony (-2.0 coverage grade) and James Anderson (-2.1 coverage grade) also struggled in coverage; Newton finished 8 of 9 for 114 yards when targeting them.

Top performers:

DT Kevin Williams (+4.5)
DE Cameron Jordan (+3.1)
CB Delvin Breaux (+2.8)
DT Tyeler Davison (+2.6)
TE Michael Hoomanawanui (+1.7)

  • Tim Edell

    Ive never seen a team in my life as bad as the Saints are in coverage. I honestly do not know how Browner is still in the league!

    • Rickn3car

      100% correct. They has it won until Cam put them on blast

    • Jonathan Seidman

      If Ginn didn’t have stones for hands and Cam was slightly more accurate, there could’ve been at least 2 more long bombs in that game…

  • Wayne deGrange

    Stephon Anthony scored 8 points from MLB position and still graded less than +1.7? I agree pass coverage wasn’t great but doesn’t scoring count for more?

    • glenda diaz

      Like Antonio responded I am taken by
      surprise that a stay at home mom able to make $5849 in a few weeks on the
      internet. have a peek at this website on my profIle



    • Rickn3car


      • Wayne deGrange

        And why not?

  • I assumed going into the game that Cooks would be shadowed by Norman, was Norman the one that was toasted for 104 yards and a touchdown?

    • Jonathan Seidman

      not positive, but i don’t think so.

      i think Carolina leaves the CBs on their side of the field and don’t shadow.

      • They’ve been using Norman to shadow the opposing #1 receiver so far, but I’m not sure if Cooks ever lines up in the slot because if he does then that’s probably where he racked up big numbers

        • Anthony Clark

          Norman shadowed him on the outside but the Saints kept motioning him inside where Norman wouldn’t follow. I think Norman was beat for a TD while in Cover 2, although I would put that on Harper more than Norman. A lot of Cooks yards came on one play over the middle when he got behind Finnigan in the slot and in between both safeties.